Many people vaguely remember reading somewhere, or being told by someone who read somewhere or watched a TV documentary, that alcohol in small amounts can be good for the heart and blood vessels. Maybe even two glasses a day, especially if they are red wine…? Or maybe it wasn’t every day…?
– No, and not even once a week! A recent research report, from a study that followed a large group of people for many years, has cleared up all the questions and doubts. Many doctors and scientists have always questioned the interpretation of epidemiological statistics from studies that seem to show that small amounts of alcohol is better than none. The charts seem to show that those who regularly drink small amounts of alcohol do better than those who abstain completely.
Oops! We’ve lost our way here already, with the wording of the last sentence. Research has not investigated whether small amounts of alcohol ‘make you feel good’ at all. What some studies have found is a statistically significant association with a reduced risk of dying before retirement or shortly after.
However, many people intuitively feel that this misrepresentation is correct. ‘Sure, I feel good drinking a glass of wine in the evening. Or two, a glass before dinner also feels just right.’ BUT now, it’s not really that kind of misconception that is the reason I’m writing this article. The problem is bigger than that. A little is better than 0 is obviously right and proper in many contexts, but not when it comes to alcohol. A great many doctors and health researchers have always objected and put forward the alternative interpretation that the cause-effect relationship goes the other way round. That is, those who already have serious health problems drink less. Sick people often abstain completely from alcoholic drinks. Many oppose this claim on the grounds that they usually have a drink or two when they feel unwell and find that it alleviates the unpleasant symptoms. This is yet another example of how tricky it can be to trust your feelings/intuition. Sure, a glass of whisky can alleviate the symptoms of a cold, but it’s more of an anaesthetic than a cure. No matter what colours and flavours it is mixed with, alcohol cannot cure an infection. For frequent and heavy drinkers, we know for sure that the opposite is true. Alcohol impairs several functions of the immune system and infections become more prolonged. In addition, it increases the risk of complications (e.g. a simple viral infection turning into a serious pneumonia, a cystitis developing into a renal pelvic inflammation, etc.)
The new research projects I referred to in the introduction have been designed differently so that not only statistically significant correlations can be obtained, but causality can be more reliably assessed. When such methodology is used to investigate the long-term health effects of alcohol, the answer is clear: the less alcohol you drink, the better for your health.
Ethanol is a solvent that certainly occurs ‘naturally’ (e.g. in overripe fruit invaded by yeasts) but neither we nor any other animal has evolved a metabolic process that can eliminate alcohol from the blood without producing harmful breakdown products. In fact, ethyl alcohol is harmful in a number of ways and even in small amounts, frequent consumption increases the risk of infections, joint and back problems, cardiac arrhythmias, high blood pressure, cerebral haemorrhages, kidney disease and cancer (particularly of the stomach, intestines and liver), as well as various forms of mental illness (mood disorders and, for most people, even worse the next day when irritability, anxiety, sleep disturbances and abnormal mental fatigue become apparent). The parts of the brain that control deep REM sleep are very sensitive to alcohol. Even after two glasses of wine in the evening (or an equivalent amount of beer, cocktail or similar), the deep dream sleep is disturbed and the mental capacity the next day is markedly impaired. Yes, it’s true; cognitive and memory tests show that there are real differences! You might not notice it yourself, especially if you’ve become used to drinking a little every night. After a while, two glasses of wine won’t make you feel as drunk as you did at the beginning (it doesn’t take long to get used to it, only 4-5 days) and you won’t get as obviously drunk and ‘hungover’. However, both physical and cognitive tests reveal that there are significant effects that occur during the night and affect your brain the next day. Performance can be reduced by 30-40% without the habitually hungover person noticing (!) because it felt the same yesterday…
Now you might be thinking: ‘You sound like a sober preacher. Don’t you ever drink a drop?’ I apologise if a preachy tone has crept into what I have said above. I am not out to ban all forms of alcohol consumption, just the ‘unnecessary drinks’, those times when you could just as easily have had something as good without alcohol. A cold beer can be delicious, but beer is not a good thirst quencher, it is not the way to correct dehydration. Wine can be a fantastic flavour enhancer with some dishes, but half a glass can be enough with a steak and a cheese plate, you only need to take a tiny sip with every other bite. I can enjoy a good drink with alcohol in it, but I consciously try to keep my consumption down to a low level and not choose an alcoholic drink unnecessarily. My knowledge of the long-term health risks associated with heavy drinking certainly contributes to my motivation to maintain this awareness and to make active drink choices, but it is also the short-term effects of alcohol that motivate me. I’ve never appreciated a ‘proper drink’, it just makes me nauseous, not more fun. I also hate being ‘hungover’. As soon as I remind myself of how I will feel tomorrow if I drink ‘too much’ tonight, it becomes easy to choose other drinks. I know I’m not representative of everyone. Some have a harder time, perhaps especially those who experience a sense of liberation when intoxication sets in, a wonderful feeling of relief when the inner discomfort is released and you can relax.
Do you drink a little too much? Or too often? Do you find it hard to hold back once you’ve downed your first beer/drink/glass? Do you walk around with a slight, nagging worry inside you? Do you get a nice feeling of relief from the tension inside when you have some alcohol? Do you sometimes find yourself longing to get home and have a drink to yourself so you can relax? – If so, you are in trouble! Send me an email and we can agree on a personalised consultation where I will explain how you can overcome mild-moderate alcohol problems. – Note: This offer is not aimed at alcoholics with even worse problems. Their problems are of a different nature and require different measures initially. If you are one of them (i.e. drink a lot, often think about and long for the next drink, have started to feel the need for ‘restorers’ in the morning, are sometimes under the influence of alcohol during the day, etc.) then you should immediately contact the nearest addiction centre in your place of residence.